By the imhoff.us Archive
Every summer, for twenty years, they came back.
They came from Clinton and Utica and Rome, from Newport and Middleville and Herkimer, from Whitesboro and New Hartford and Syracuse and, in some years, from as far as New York City and Bridgeport, Connecticut. They came by automobile along the roads of Oneida County on August Sunday afternoons, carrying covered dishes and dressed in their summer clothes, and they gathered on a lawn or in a grove or at a set of athletic fields that bore the family name, and they ate together and ran races and elected officers and reported on the births and deaths and marriages of the year just passed, and then they went home again and waited for the following summer.
The Pryor family reunions, held annually from 1919 to 1938, were documented in the pages of the Clinton Courier, the Waterville Times, and the Utica Daily Press. They are, taken together, one of the most vivid records in the imhoff.us archive of what it meant to be an Irish Catholic family in Oneida County in the years between the two World Wars. They are also a record of how a family that had arrived from the Famine ships in December 1853 had, within two generations, become so thoroughly rooted in the soil of Kirkland and Clinton that they had athletic fields named after them and a hundred relatives within driving distance every August.
What follows is as complete an account of those twenty reunions as the surviving newspaper record permits.
The Family That Gathered
To understand the reunions, it helps to understand the family that held them.
James Daniel Pryor was born in Ireland on March 16, 1830, the son of John Pryor and Anne Kiernan. He married Margaret Robinson, also born in Ireland in 1833, at Saint Mary’s Church in Clinton on January 8, 1853, and the two of them stepped off the ship James Fitz in New York Harbor on December 19 of that same year. They settled in the Kirkland area near the iron works, embedded themselves in the Irish Catholic community forming around St. Mary’s Church on Marvin Street, and set about building a family.
James Daniel and Margaret Robinson had eight children, all born in the United States, between 1855 and 1877:
Thomas J., born April 27, 1855, died July 15, 1930. John, born August 13, 1856, died March 14, 1904. William Christopher, born July 27, 1859, died June 15, 1930. Margaret E., born November 4, 1863, died March 13, 1958. Edward Patrick, born September 8, 1870, died October 18, 1871, in infancy. Daniel Henry, born April 20, 1872, died September 15, 1953. Emma, born April 10, 1876, died November 26, 1877, also in infancy. And Mary Elizabeth, known as Minnie, born October 13, 1877, died December 27, 1950.
Six children survived to adulthood, and their children and grandchildren were the people who filled the lawns and groves of Kirkland every August through the 1920s and 1930s. By 1919, when the first reunion was held, those descendants had spread across a substantial portion of upstate New York, in a dozen communities connected by the roads and railroads of Oneida County, and held together by the bonds of faith, blood, and the particular kind of Irish Catholic community loyalty that St. Mary’s had been building since the 1850s.
Margaret Robinson Pryor died in 1898, twenty-one years before the first reunion was held. James Daniel lived to see it. He was 89 years old in the summer of 1919, a man born in Famine Ireland who had spent 66 years watching his family grow from two immigrant newcomers into a community that needed a hundred chairs to seat itself.
The First Reunion: August 17, 1919
The summer of 1919 was a complicated one in American life. The Great War had ended the previous November, and the boys of Kirkland and Clinton were coming home. Woodrow Wilson was in Europe trying to negotiate a peace that Congress would ultimately refuse to ratify. Race riots had broken out in Chicago and other American cities in what historians would call the Red Summer. Prohibition was less than a year away from taking effect. The country was in one of those transitional moments when one era has ended and the next has not yet fully arrived.
None of this, or very little of it, would have been the subject of conversation at Thomas Pryor’s farm on Pryor Road off the Seneca Turnpike in Kirkland that Sunday afternoon. What mattered was the family, and the family was there. Eighty guests attended this first reunion, served dinner in the dancing hall given that the weather, as the newspaper account noted, was inclement on this day.
The entertainment was entirely homemade, in the way of the era. Miss Veronica Pryor sang vocal solos. Stanley and Mrs. Autenrith performed a violin and cornet duet. Mrs. Lawrence Seavey played piano solos. Master Terence Autenrith also sang. The Autenrith family appeared repeatedly in the reunion records, connected to the Pryors through the marriage of James Daniel’s sister, Mary Pryor, to Jacob Autenrith in 1860. They were family, in the full Irish Catholic sense of the word.
Thomas Pryor, the host, was the eldest surviving son of James Daniel and Margaret Robinson. He had been born in April 1855, two years after his parents arrived from Ireland, the first American-born Pryor, a man whose very existence measured the distance the family had traveled from the Famine ship to the Kirkland farm. His decision to open his home and his farm to the extended family that summer of 1919 was an act of both hospitality and civic memory, a declaration that these people, scattered now across a dozen communities, were still one family and would gather to say so.
The Middle Years: Finding a Pattern, 1920 to 1925
The newspaper record has gaps. The reunions of 1920, 1921, 1922, 1923, and 1924 are not covered in the surviving press accounts available to the archive. We know they were held, because the record refers to the 7th annual reunion in 1925, counting back from a first in 1919. We know that James Daniel Pryor, the patriarch whose very existence had given the whole enterprise its meaning, died on October 16, 1921, at the age of 91, at the family home in Lairdsville, Oneida County. The Clinton Courier noted his passing, calling him “one of the pioneer residents and one who enjoyed the esteem and respect of all who knew him.” He had lived long enough to see the first gathering of his descendants. He did not live to see the seventh.
By 1925, the reunion had established the format it would keep for the rest of its run. A hundred guests. A Sunday in August. Dinner on the lawn when the weather permitted. A formal meeting with elected officers, a report on the year’s births and deaths and marriages, and races and prizes for the children. It was, in structure, half church social and half county fair, the kind of event that small-town Irish Catholic families in upstate New York had been organizing since they first had enough relatives to fill a field.
The 7th Annual Reunion: August 1925
The Clinton Courier of Wednesday, August 12, 1925 carried the account of the 7th annual Pryor Family reunion, held at the home of James Pryor, the youngest son of James Daniel and Margaret Robinson.
One hundred guests attended, drawn from Clinton, Utica, Kirkland, Sherrill, Newport, New Hartford, Norwich, Herkimer, Rome, Syracuse, Middleville, Whitesboro, Mohawk, and New York City. The geographic spread of that list tells its own story. The Pryor family had moved in every direction from the original Kirkland farm, following employment and marriage into the mill towns and manufacturing cities of upstate New York, and some had gone much further, to New York City and Connecticut. But they came back in August.
Officers elected at the 1925 reunion were: President, Thomas Jones; Vice President, Mrs. Arthur Peterson; Secretary, Miss Florence Caraher; Secretary, Jacob Autenrith; and Miss Margaret E. Pryor, chairman of the flower committee.
Miss Margaret E. Pryor, the daughter of James Daniel and Margaret Robinson born during the Civil War in 1863, would appear in these reunion records with admirable regularity across the following decade, serving as flower committee chair, historian, and simply as a presence, the living link to the generation that had arrived from Ireland. She was 61 years old at the 1925 reunion, and she would attend them into the 1930s.
Three deaths and one birth were reported for the year. Rita Mary Sheridan, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. John Sheridan, received a prize as the youngest person present. The family voted to hold the eighth reunion at the home of Mrs. John Pryor on College Street in Clinton.
The mid-1920s was the height of the Jazz Age in America. Calvin Coolidge was in the White House. The Charleston was on every dance floor. F. Scott Fitzgerald had just published The Great Gatsby. Al Capone was running Chicago. None of that particular American modernity was likely the soundtrack of the Pryor reunion on the Kirkland lawn, where the entertainment leaned toward family music and the conversations leaned toward local news. But the prosperity of the era, what Coolidge called the “business of America,” was real in Oneida County too. The families who gathered in 1925 were doing well enough, employed in the mills and farms and trades of the region, and the hundred guests who made the drive to Kirkland that August Sunday were evidence of it.
The 8th Annual Reunion: August 15, 1926
Despite the vote to hold the eighth reunion at the home of Mrs. John Pryor on College Street in Clinton, it was held instead at the “Pryor Athletic Fields,” thought to be located on Pryor Road just off of the Seneca Turnpike near Route 233. The change of venue may reflect the size of the gathering, since a hundred people require a good deal more lawn than most private homes could provide.
Articles about the reunion appeared in the Wednesday, August 19th editions of both the Clinton Courier and the Waterville Times, a sign that the family reunion had achieved sufficient community standing to warrant coverage in two local papers simultaneously.
The guest list recorded in the newspaper is the most complete of any reunion in the archive, a remarkable snapshot of the extended Pryor family and its connected surnames in the summer of 1926:
Miss Margaret E. Pryor, Clinton. Mr. and Mrs. Daniel Pryor and family, Clinton. William Pryor and Miss Theresa Pryor, Clinton. Mr. and Mrs. John E. Pryor and Family, Clinton. Mr. and Mrs. Thomas Pryor, Clinton. Mr. and Mrs. Vincent Pryor and Family, Clinton. Mr. and Mrs. Charles Pratt and family, Utica. Mrs. Martin Caraher and Family, Utica. Donald Dolan, New York. Neal Pryor, Whitesboro. Mr. and Mrs. James J. Dwyer and family, Utica. Mr. and Mrs. William Pryor, Kirkland. Mr. and Mrs. Jacob Autenrith and family, Newport. Miss Catherine C. Connelly, Port Richmond. Mr. and Mrs. Peterson and family, New Hartford. Mr. and Mrs. O’Toole and family, Utica. Mrs. Stanley O’Toole, Utica. Miss Anne O’Toole, Utica. James Pryor, Bridgeport, Connecticut. Mr. and Mrs. Matt Kernan and family, Rome. Mr. and Mrs. William Autenrith and family, Middleville. Miss Amelia and Miss Minnie Autenrith, Middleville. Mr. and Mrs. Louis Remmer, Utica. Mr. and Mrs. Thomas Jones and Family, Utica. Miss Mattie and Miss Anna Pryor, Utica. Mr. and Mrs. John Sheridan and family, Clinton. Mr. and Mrs. Francis Feeney, Utica.
The surnames in that list are the surnames of the Pryor world: Pryor, Autenrith, Caraher, O’Toole, Sheridan, Dwyer, Kernan, Feeney. Irish Catholic names, all of them, the product of the same Famine-era emigration that had brought James Daniel and Margaret Robinson to Kirkland in 1853, and all now resident in the communities within a day’s drive of the Pryor Athletic Fields. One guest, James Pryor of Bridgeport, Connecticut, had traveled the furthest, a branch of the family that had moved entirely out of Oneida County.
The 9th Annual Reunion: August 21, 1927
The ninth annual Pryor Reunion returned to the Pryor Family Athletic Fields on Pryor Road on Sunday, August 21, 1927. The account of the reunion appeared in the Tuesday, August 23rd edition of the Utica Daily Press, which noted that 100 individuals were present.
The summer of 1927 was the summer Charles Lindbergh flew the Atlantic alone, landing in Paris on May 21 to a reception that made him the most famous man in the world. Babe Ruth was on his way to hitting 60 home runs. Al Jolson’s The Jazz Singer would open in October, ushering in the era of talking pictures. The prosperity of the decade felt permanent to most Americans that summer, and the families gathering on Pryor Road had little reason to think otherwise.
The 10th Annual Reunion: August 19, 1928
The 10th annual Pryor reunion marked a return to a private home, held on Sunday, August 19, 1928 at the home of Daniel Pryor on Kirkland Hill. Daniel Henry Pryor, the sixth child of James Daniel and Margaret Robinson, born in 1872, was now 56 years old and living on Kirkland Hill, and his home would serve as the reunion’s primary venue for much of the remainder of the series.
An account appeared in the Wednesday, August 22nd, 1928 edition of the Clinton Courier. Approximately 80 individuals were present, a smaller gathering than the hundred who had appeared in the years at the Athletic Fields, but the list of communities represented remained broad: Newport, Herkimer, Utica, Clinton, New Hartford, Kirkland, Rome, and Syracuse.
The summer of 1928 was the last summer of American prosperity for a long time. Hoover would win the presidency in November, and the stock market was still climbing. No one at Daniel Pryor’s reunion that August Sunday had any reason to know that in a little over a year, the world would change entirely.
The 11th Annual Reunion: August 18, 1929
The 11th annual Pryor reunion was held on Sunday, August 18, 1929, again at the home of Daniel Pryor on Kirkland Hill, and the Clinton Courier of August 22, 1929 gave it its fullest account in years.
“The weather was ideal,” the paper noted, “and tables were set up on the spacious lawn.” At noon, a “bountiful” dinner was served, after which a meeting was called to order by the president, Edward O’Toole of Utica. The business of the reunion was conducted with the formality that these gatherings had developed over a decade: officers were elected, committees formed, prizes awarded, and the year’s vital statistics recorded.
Officers chosen were: President, Edward O’Toole; Vice President, Thomas Jones of 1015 Churchill Avenue, Utica; Secretary, Mrs. A.N. Peterson of New Hartford; Treasurer, Jacob Autenrith of Middleville. The entertainment committee was composed of Mr. and Mrs. William Pryor, Kirkland; Mr. and Mrs. John Sheridan, Clinton; and Miss Florence and Harold Caraher, Utica. The sports program was in charge of Edward O’Toole, Thomas Jones, and James Dwyer.
The prizes and races give the most vivid picture of what the afternoon actually felt like. Secret time race for women: Mrs. Julia Allen, Sauquoit. Marshmallow race: Mrs. Daniel Pryor, Kirkland Hill. Peanut race: Mrs. John E. Pryor, Clinton. Time race for men: John Toomey, Utica. Running race for men: William Pryor, Kirkland. Little girls’ race: Rosemary O’Toole, Utica. Little boys’ race: Lysle Pryor, Clinton. Prize for youngest baby: little Ann Feeney, Utica.
A marshmallow race and a peanut race, a running race for men and a prize for the youngest baby. These are the details that the newspaper preserved, almost by accident, and that nothing else would have saved. The afternoon on Daniel Pryor’s lawn in August 1929 is alive in those small particulars in a way it would not be if the account had only recorded the officers and the guest list.
Report was given of one death, two births, and two weddings. Guests were present from New York City, Bridgeport, Newport, Middleville, Herkimer, Utica, Whitesboro, Clinton, New Hartford, Rome, and Syracuse. The next reunion was planned for Newport.
Two months and nine days after this reunion, on October 29, 1929, the stock market crashed. Black Tuesday ended the prosperity of the decade and sent the American economy into the spiral that would define the 1930s. The families who had gathered so contentedly on Daniel Pryor’s lawn in August would spend the next years navigating the Depression in the mill towns and farming communities of Oneida County.
The Depression Years: Reunions 12 Through 16, 1930 to 1934
The reunions continued through the Depression without interruption, which is itself a statement about the Pryor family’s priorities and, perhaps, about the function the gatherings served. In hard times, a day spent with a hundred relatives on a familiar lawn, eating a potluck dinner and watching the children run races, is not a luxury. It is a necessity of a different kind.
The 12th reunion details are not preserved in the available newspaper record, but the 13th annual Pryor reunion, held at the home of Daniel Pryor on Sunday, August 16, 1931, appears in the archive. A basket picnic was served, a modest step down from the “bountiful dinner” of 1929, perhaps reflecting the economic strains of the era. In the afternoon, a meeting was called by the president, Daniel Pryor, and officers were elected: President, Daniel Pryor, Kirkland; Vice President, J.E. O’Toole, Utica; Treasurer, J.B. Autenrith, Newport; Secretary, Katherine L. Jones, Utica.
Races were run and prizes were awarded to Maureen O’Toole, Mrs. Frank Pryor, Eunice Volmer, Harry Pryor, Donald Pryor, and Francis Feeney. One death and one birth were reported during the year. The family voted to hold the following year’s reunion at the same place, Daniel Pryor’s home on Kirkland Hill, which had by now become the de facto permanent home of the gathering.
The 14th annual Pryor reunion was held on Sunday, August 21, 1932, at the home of Daniel Pryor. A luncheon was served at noon. Officers elected were: President, James J. Dwyer, Utica; Vice President, Mary E. Pryor, Utica; Secretary, Kathryn Jones, Utica, and Jacob Autenrith, Newport. The entertainment committee was Mr. and Mrs. Louis Remmer and Mr. and Mrs. James Dwyer. The sports committee was Edward O’Toole and Thomas Jones. Prizes were won by Stanley Autenrith, Mrs. Vincent Pryor, Rita Sheridan, Alice Volmer, Shirley Volmer, Harold Pryor, and Harry Pryor.
By 1932, Franklin Roosevelt was running for president on the promise of a New Deal. Unemployment had reached 23 percent nationally. Oneida County’s mills were running reduced shifts or not at all. The families gathering at Daniel Pryor’s that August Sunday were living through the worst of it, and still they came.
The 16th annual reunion was held at the home of Daniel Pryor in Kirkland on Sunday afternoon, August 18, 1934. Officers elected: President, Daniel Pryor; Vice President, Roy Caraher, Utica; Secretary, Miss Kathryn L. Jones, Utica; Treasurer, Jacob B. Autenrith, Newport. Plans were made to hold the 1935 reunion at the home of Mr. and Mrs. J.B. Autenrith in Newport, marking a rare departure from Kirkland Hill.
The 18th Annual Reunion: August 16, 1936
The 18th annual Pryor reunion was held at Newport Grove on August 16, 1936, a departure from the usual Kirkland Hill setting that suggests the Autenrith branch of the family was taking a larger role in the organization.
Officers named were: President, Daniel Pryor, Kirkland; Vice President, Roy Caraher, Utica; Secretary, Mrs. Kathryn L. Jones, Utica; Treasurer, Jacob Autenrith, Newport; and, notably, Historian, Miss Margaret Pryor of Kirkland.
The addition of a formal “Historian” role to the reunion’s officer slate is significant. By 1936, the reunion was in its eighteenth year, James Daniel Pryor had been dead for fifteen years, and the generation that remembered him as a living presence was aging. The decision to name a Historian, charged with preserving the family’s memory, was an acknowledgment that the story needed tending. Miss Margaret Pryor of Kirkland accepted that responsibility.
Plans were made to hold the 19th reunion at the home of Daniel Pryor in Kirkland on August 15, 1937.
The summer of 1936 was the summer Jesse Owens won four gold medals at the Berlin Olympics, humiliating Hitler’s racial ideology on the world stage. In America, the New Deal was being contested in the courts and celebrated at the ballot box. Swing music was everywhere. Benny Goodman had played Carnegie Hall for the first time. The families gathering at Newport Grove that August Sunday were living in a decade that was both deeply troubled and unexpectedly vital, and the reunion, in its modest annual persistence, was its own form of vitality.
The 20th and Final Reunion: August 27, 1938
The 20th Pryor reunion was held at the home of Daniel Pryor in Kirkland on Saturday, August 27, 1938, a Saturday rather than the traditional Sunday, a small departure from the established pattern.
Forty guests were present, a significant reduction from the hundred who had gathered through the 1920s. The Depression, combined with the aging and death of the founding generation, had taken its toll on the family’s ability to turn out in strength. Thomas J. Pryor, the eldest son of James Daniel and Margaret Robinson and the host of the very first reunion in 1919, had died in 1930. William Christopher Pryor had also died in 1930. The generation that had founded the tradition was passing.
Officers elected for the following year’s reunion: President, Daniel Pryor; Vice President, Thomas Jones; Treasurer, Jacob Autenrith; Secretary, Florence Caraher; Historian, Margaret Pryor.
This was the last reunion covered by the local newspapers. No record exists of a 21st reunion. Whether the outbreak of World War II in Europe in September 1939, or the changing circumstances of the family, or simply the natural attrition of a tradition dependent on the energy of a particular generation, the Pryor Family reunions came to an end somewhere between 1938 and 1940. They had run for twenty years.
What the Reunions Were
There is a comment in the imhoff.us archive, posted in December 2018 by Mary Lou Studley Newstead, that reads: “I am a descendant of John Sheridan and Mary Pryor Sheridan. Rita Sheridan Studley is my mother and she is alive and well at 93 in Rochester, NY.”
Rita Sheridan, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. John Sheridan of Clinton, had been the youngest person present at the 7th reunion in 1925, receiving a prize for the distinction. She was born sometime around 1925, which means she was present at the reunion as an infant, held by her parents in the summer shade on Daniel Pryor’s lawn. She grew up to be 93 years old in Rochester, still remembered by her daughter, who found the imhoff.us archive and left a note.
That is what the reunions were. They were the mechanism by which a family that had arrived from Ireland with nothing, in December 1853, reproduced itself socially across the generations. The children who ran the little girls’ and little boys’ races in the 1920s and 1930s grew up knowing they were Pryors, knowing the names of their cousins from Utica and Rome and Newport, knowing the faces of the aunts and uncles who appeared each August on the familiar lawn. They carried that knowledge into their own lives and, in some cases, passed it to their children, who eventually found their way to a genealogical archive and left a comment.
James Daniel Pryor arrived in Clinton in December 1853. He and Margaret Robinson raised eight children on the soil of Oneida County. Those children and their children held twenty family reunions between 1919 and 1938, and the Clinton Courier recorded most of them. The archive preserves what the newspaper saved.
That is how a family stays a family across the generations: by gathering, by naming officers and flower committees, by running marshmallow races and awarding prizes to the youngest baby present, by reading the year’s list of births and deaths and marriages aloud to everyone who came, by doing this every August for twenty years on a hill in Kirkland, New York, until the world changed too much and the generation that had held it together was gone.
A Note on the Record
The reunion accounts are drawn from the following sources: the Clinton Courier, Wednesday editions of August 12, 1925; August 19, 1926; August 22, 1928; and August 22, 1929. The 9th reunion is documented in the Utica Daily Press, August 23, 1927. The 8th reunion also appeared in the Waterville Times, August 19, 1926. The first reunion account is preserved in the imhoff.us archive through the research of Joseph Daniel Pryor, whose gathering of family records forms the foundation of everything documented here about the Pryor line.
Gaps in the record, specifically the reunions of 1920 through 1924, the 12th, 15th, and 17th annual reunions, and the 19th annual reunion, reflect the limits of the newspaper archive rather than the absence of the events themselves. The full run of the Clinton Courier on microfilm is held at the New York State Library and the Utica Public Library. Any family member who locates additional reunion accounts in those archives is encouraged to contribute them to the imhoff.us archive through the Contact page.
This article was compiled from records in the imhoff.us genealogical database, newspaper accounts in the Clinton Courier, the Waterville Times, and the Utica Daily Press, and from the research of Joseph Daniel Pryor. If you are a descendant of any of the Pryor, Autenrith, Caraher, O’Toole, Sheridan, Dwyer, Kernan, or connected families documented in this article, the archive welcomes your contributions at the Contact page.